iPad policy in the Queensland State Election.
Here in Queensland, Australia, we’re just at the start of a new state election campaign, one that sounds like it’s going to be bitterly fought on all fronts and particularly nasty. The ruling Labor government is looking for a sixth consecutive term while the Liberal-National party (LNP) hopes to win government by relying on Campbell Newman, the former Lord Mayor of Brisbane, and a leader who doesn’t hold a state seat.
Let me state now that the following represents my own opinion and not that of my employer. Just in case that wasn’t clear enough already.
I had mentioned on Facebook yesterday that the LNP had come out with ‘policy’ that promised 6,000 ipads to be supplied to special education schools, exasperating that this was sensationalist, empty policy that gives money to tech companies and will have little benefit for educators.
I’m not a teacher or even involved in educating children in any way shape or form, but I don’t understand how handing out tablet computers suddenly benefits the education system at large. And I’m not going to pick on the LNP here exclusively, because Labor came out and announced a very similar policy, justifying it by stating that they want our children to have access to the latest technology.
Read about Labor’s policy initiative – using mining boom to give students iPads
LNP criticises Labor’s iPad policy
LNPs iPad policy initiative announced back in November
I have a large number of questions regarding initiatives such as these. Is there any special reason why tablet computers have been chosen? Why provide them to a small number of students? (at least, in the LNP case, the policy is focused on special needs). Is there any research available to suggest having access tablet computers provides tangible benefits for the young over alternatives (for instance, netbooks)? Why iPads when there are cheaper, just as capable alternatives on the market? The various media reports don’t indicate any answers to these questions.
This means, for me, policies such as handing out iPads willy-nilly are not policy at all, but rather things to grab headlines, and fool people into thinking the major parties have solutions for problems, particularly in education.




